Are you giving feedback people can actually use?
We need to up our feedback game
I’ve been reflecting on the business of managing people. Over the past few weeks I’ve been running various leadership and management courses, both in-house and in agencies, for people with quite different levels of experience.
And, if there’s one thing I’ve learnt, it’s that we NEVER stop learning when it comes to people management!
One of the most vital components for team success is a coaching culture. And, at the heart of that culture is giving and receiving feedback. Not just once a year at an appraisal meeting where one (or both!) parties can come away feeling dissatisfied if a single conversation doesn’t go the way they were expecting it to go. But ongoing and constant feedback that helps propel the whole team forward.
Why good feedback is so important
The need for reassurance is deeply human. We need it to feel secure in our work, to feel a sense of belonging and we need it for our own self-esteem.
That reassurance needs to be grounded in evidence that is specific about our individual progress. If all we hear is "Great job! Go dream team! Yay!", it’s quite nice but quickly becomes rather meaningless.
At the same time, managers can feel stuck because they know the team is not flying in the way that it should and could, despite liberal praise and their motivational Monday morning chats.
We must learn to deliver feedback so that it’s heard well, know what to do when people don’t action our suggestions, and stop beating the same drum when we can see it isn’t working.We must learn to deliver feedback so that it’s heard well, know what to do when people don’t action our suggestions, and stop beating the same drum when we can see it isn’t working.
In short, we need to up our feedback game!
A two-way street
The more experienced we get, the harder it is to remember how far we’ve come. We forget all the things we’ve learnt over the years, and how much time and space we needed to get where we are.
We need to give others that time and space to learn (and...yes!...to make mistakes) but, because we’ve forgotten our own experiences, we sometimes miss the mark. As managers and leaders, we simply expect people to be able to interpret feedback correctly.
Partly that’s about giving feedback well (of course!). That means focusing not just on the gaps in knowledge and progress but also on the gains team members have made.
[Feedback] isn’t a verdict on the person.It also helps to offer feedback as perspective rather than judgement. What you’re sharing is your view of how something landed and what might make it even stronger next time. It isn’t a verdict on the person. "This isn’t quite there," leaves them guessing, and probably worrying. Whereas "I felt the key message got a bit lost in the third paragraph," is something people can work with.
Then there’s the power dynamic, which we can’t pretend isn’t there. When the person giving the feedback also has a say in your appraisal, your pay rise or your next promotion, even the gentlest suggestion can land with a thud. People may nod along in the meeting when what they actually mean is, "I don’t agree," or "I have absolutely no idea what you want me to do differently,". Just being aware of that makes a difference.
And some people find feedback much harder to hear than others. For some neurodivergent people, rejection-sensitive dysphoria (RSD) can mean that even mild criticism, or something that simply feels like criticism, triggers an intense emotional response. You won’t always know who in your team experiences this, which is one more reason to be clear, specific and kind, and to check in afterwards.
But it is also a two-way street. Individual team members need to be able to tell the difference between constructive comments aimed at helping them learn and grow, and criticism. They need time and space to process feedback, and the confidence to come back and ask for clarification, or even to argue their own perspective.
If people know that questions and a bit of respectful pushback are genuinely welcome, they’re far more likely to really hear what you’re saying.That confidence partly comes from the manager. If people know that questions and a bit of respectful pushback are genuinely welcome, they’re far more likely to really hear what you’re saying.
Set up for success
Here are three elements worth exploring if you are trying to embed a coaching culture into your team.
- Do you understand your people? Different individuals take on feedback in different ways so you need to adapt your style accordingly. How does each best receive feedback? Do they want you to follow up regularly, or do they prefer a light touch and the space to improve in their own time? You can ask them of course, but they might not know yet! So observe and offer opportunities for discussion when they’re ready.
- Are you giving yourself enough time to step back and think about where everybody is? Not just in the half an hour before an appraisal meeting but on a weekly/monthly/quarterly basis?
- And are you open to feedback on your feedback?! This sounds a bit ridiculous, but listening to your team is a vital part of creating a positive coaching culture. Most team members will be nervous about offering any kind of feedback on the boss that could be perceived as criticism, but a few questions can help them to open up (the more specific the better). "We meet once a month, is this working for you? Is there anything you would change?"
Brilliant People Management
Finally, if you or someone on your team needs a little more guidance on management skills, I’m running a Brilliant People Management course early next year. It’s made up of two half-day sessions that will cover: delegation that works, giving feedback without feeling awkward, handling difficult conversations, and motivating people and helping them grow.
Brilliant People Management is an open course and places are limited to keep the sessions interactive. It will take place live and online on 27 January and 11 February 2027 and you can register your interest here.
It’s £349+VAT per person if you book by 31 December 2026 and £449+VAT after that. A second delegate can attend for £325+VAT regardless of when the first place is booked.
Further Reading
How Big Fish Training Works
Got a team to train? Most courses are delivered direct either in person or via live video for groups of 6 - 12 people. These sessions are tailored to your specific needs. You just need to tell us what they are! Get in touch now for a friendly chat about what you need to achieve.
Want a course just for you? We run special sessions throughout the year and have a growing number of online courses. If you can't find what you need on the site, get in touch now and we can help.
Read More
Sign up for The Hook
Get notified about our next webinar